Only one rook check wins

White has an extra pawn, but twelve of its thirteen legal moves throw away the win. Stockfish 18 finds that only one, a forcing rook check, reaches a winning king-and-pawn ending.

The position

White to move.

  1. 1.Ra8+ Ke7 2.Rxf8 Kxf8 3.Kf6.

Why does this work?

1.Ra8+! is the only winning move. The check forces the black king onto the seventh rank, after which 2.Rxf8 exchanges the rooks under favorable conditions. Any quiet rook move or the immediate 1.b5 allows Black to draw.

The point appears after 2...Kxf8 3.Kf6!. White wins the opposition and escorts the b-pawn while the black king is one tempo too far away. Even here, pushing 3.b5? instead would draw, so the king move is part of the calculation.

This is a useful puzzle precisely because the first move looks like simplification rather than attack. In rook endings, calculate the pawn ending before agreeing to a trade: king position and move order matter more than the extra pawn by itself.

One move out of thirteen

White has thirteen legal moves, and Stockfish 18 scores only 1.Ra8+ as winning: the quiet rook moves and 1.b5 all come out at about level. The check forces the black king to the seventh rank, 2.Rxf8 trades rooks, and after 2...Kxf8 3.Kf6 White has the opposition and the extra pawn.

The second only move

The work is not over after the trade. In the pawn ending Stockfish 18 again finds a single winning move, 3.Kf6, taking the opposition. 3.b5, 3.Kf4 and 3.Kf5 all let the black king come back in time, and the engine scores them about level. Two only-moves in a row are what make this a puzzle.

What else was playable?

Stockfish 18 at the starting position, from White’s side:

  • 1.Ra8+: Winning: forces the trade into a won pawn ending.
  • 1.Ra7: About +0.3. A draw.
  • 1.b5: About 0.0. A draw.

What to take away

  • Before trading into a pawn ending, calculate it to the end; the trade is only good if the king ending wins.
  • In king and pawn endings, the opposition often matters more than the extra pawn.

Want a looping version of a position like this? Create an animated chess GIF with the Chess GIF Maker.