Italian Game: the strike on f7
f7 is the weakest square on the board, and the bishop sacrifice against it is the most copied idea in chess. Here it does not work — and seeing why is worth more than another example where it does.
The position
White to move.
- 1.Bxf7+ Rxf7 2.Ng5 Rf8.
Why does this work?
The pattern looks right: bishop aiming at f7, knight ready for g5, king castled behind three pawns. But Black simply recaptures with the rook, drops it back to f8, and White has given a bishop for one pawn with no follow-up. An engine puts Black more than three pawns ahead.
The prerequisites for a sound f7 sacrifice are concrete, not decorative: the king must be forced into the open, and every check that follows must gain material or tempo. Here Black’s king never leaves g8, the knight on g5 attacks a rook that just steps aside, and the d7 bishop covers the entry squares.
A brilliancy is a move that survives the opponent’s best answer. This one does not, which is exactly why it belongs next to the ones that do — the exclamation mark has to be earned.
Count the material when the dust settles
After 1.Bxf7+ Rxf7 2.Ng5 Rf8 White has given a bishop for one pawn, and nothing black is attacked. The knight on g5 eyes f7 and h7, but f7 is now empty and h7 is guarded by the king. Stockfish 18 puts the position at about −3.6 from White’s side, and there is no second wave: the queen is still on d1, no rook stands on an open file, and the king on g8 is exactly as safe as before.
The famous versions of this sacrifice work because the king has to recapture and then meets Ng5+ with check. Here the rook recaptures, the king never moves, and Ng5 comes without check, so Black has all the time needed to step the rook back and keep the extra piece.
What White should play instead
Nothing forcing. Stockfish 18 prefers slow moves such as 1.a4, 1.h3 and 1.a3, each worth about +1.8 to +1.9, which keep the bishop aimed at f7 and prepare Nd5 or queenside space. Even 1.Ng5 on its own, without giving up the bishop first, is about +0.8: the pressure on f7 is worth more as a threat than as a capture.
What else was playable?
Stockfish 18 at the starting position, from White’s side:
- 1.a4: About +1.9. Takes queenside space and keeps every option.
- 1.h3: About +1.9. Takes g4 away from the d7-bishop first.
- 1.Ng5: About +0.8. Puts the question to f7 without paying for it.
- 1.Bxf7+: About −3.6 after 1...Rxf7 2.Ng5 Rf8. The bishop is simply gone.
What to take away
- Before sacrificing on f7, ask which piece recaptures. If it is not the king, the checks that make the sacrifice work usually do not exist.
- A sacrifice has to win something concrete within a few moves: material back, a mating attack, or a king dragged into the open.
- When the pressure is good, keeping it is often stronger than cashing it in.
Want a looping version of a position like this? Create an animated chess GIF with the Chess GIF Maker.
Sources
- Italian Game — The opening this middlegame comes from.
Read next: Two Knights: a balanced middlegame, The smothered mate, Rook mate in one and Classic Replay template.