Rotlewi–Rubinstein: an immortal combination

Akiba Rubinstein’s 1907 win over Georg Rotlewi is a model of piece coordination, ending with a combination in which Black gives up the queen and a rook to force mate.

Complete game score

25 moves. Result: 0-1.

  1. 1.d4 d5 2.Nf3 e6 3.e3 c5 4.c4 Nc6 5.Nc3 Nf6 6.dxc5 Bxc5.
  2. 7.a3 a6 8.b4 Bd6 9.Bb2 O-O 10.Qd2 Qe7 11.Bd3 dxc4 12.Bxc4 b5.
  3. 13.Bd3 Rd8 14.Qe2 Bb7 15.O-O Ne5 16.Nxe5 Bxe5 17.f4 Bc7 18.e4 Rac8.
  4. 19.e5 Bb6+ 20.Kh1 Ng4 21.Be4 Qh4 22.g3 Rxc3 23.gxh4 Rd2 24.Qxd2 Bxe4+
  5. 25.Qg2 Rh3.

What happened in this game?

Rubinstein’s pieces converge before 22...Rxc3!, when the rook removes a defender and cannot be taken without opening decisive lines. White instead takes the queen with 23.gxh4; the alternatives were no better, since 23.Bxc3 runs into 23...Bxe4+ 24.Qxe4 Qxh2#.

The reply 23...Rd2 forces White’s queen onto d2, and 24...Bxe4+ activates the bishop with check. After 25.Qg2 Rh3, mate is unavoidable despite Black having given up the queen; the two bishops and the remaining rook cover every escape, and ...Rxh2# follows.

Replay the final phase while tracking functions rather than values. The c3-rook removes a guard, the d8-rook enters with tempo, and both bishops cut the king’s position apart. Every sacrifice accelerates a concrete line.

A symmetrical opening and an offered pawn

The game was played in Łódź, Poland, on 26 December 1907. Hans Kmoch named it Rubinstein’s Immortal Game, and Garry Kasparov called it Rubinstein’s most famous creation. It began as a Symmetrical Tarrasch, a branch of the Queen’s Gambit Declined.

Tartakower criticised 10.Qd2 as a loss of time and recommended 10.Qc2, but Stockfish 18 finds almost nothing between them; both are close to level. Black’s reply 10...Qe7 offered a pawn, and taking it with 11.cxd5 exd5 12.Nxd5 would have run into 12...Nxd5 13.Qxd5 Rd8 and a strong attack.

Where White went wrong

By the engine’s count the decisive mistake came before the sacrifices. 19.e5 cost about two pawns: Stockfish rates it at about −4, against about −1.9 for 19.Kh1. After 19...Bb6+ 20.Kh1 Ng4 both of Black’s bishops, the knight and soon the queen were aimed at White’s king.

Earlier, 16...Bxe5 had threatened 17...Bxh2+, since 18.Kxh2 would allow the fork 18...Qd6+ and 19...Qxd3, and White’s 17.f4 parried it by driving the bishop back to c7.

By move 22 White was already lost, and 22.g3, attacking the queen, made it worse. The engine prefers 22.h3, though that is still about four pawns down for White.

The combination

22...Rxc3!! left the queen en prise and took the knight that defended the bishop on e4. White’s queen now had two jobs, guarding e4 and the h2-square, and could not do both. Stockfish rates the move about −7.5, against about −2.7 for the next best, and Kmoch gave it three exclamation marks.

Taking the queen with 23.gxh4 allowed a forced mate, but the alternatives were no better: 23.Bxc3 loses to 23...Bxe4+ 24.Qxe4 Qxh2#, and 23.Bxb7, which avoids mate, still leaves White about seven and a half pawns down.

23...Rd2!! gave up a rook as well, and every White reply now allows mate: 24.Qe1 Rxh2# at once, 24.Qxg4 Bxe4+ 25.Rf3 Rxf3 with mate by the bishop to follow, and the game’s 24.Qxd2 Bxe4+ 25.Qg2 Rh3, after which ...Rxh2# cannot be stopped. Even 24.Bxb7 fails to 24...Rxe2 25.Bg2 Rh3.

Mate instead of the queen

At the end Black was down a queen and a rook for two minor pieces, and still mating. Rubinstein ignored the chance to take White’s queen: 25...Bxg2+ would have left Black only about a pawn and a half better, while 25...Rh3 forces mate. White has 20 legal moves in the final position, and none of them avoids mate within three moves.

What else was playable?

Stockfish 18 at the moments that decided the game, from White’s point of view:

  • 10.Qc2 (instead of 10.Qd2): About −0.2, no better than the game move despite Tartakower’s criticism.
  • 19.Kh1 (instead of 19.e5): About −1.9. The game move is about −4 and let Black’s pieces in.
  • 25...Bxg2+ (instead of 25...Rh3): About −1.4: it wins the queen but lets White survive. 25...Rh3 forces mate.

What to take away

  • Count the jobs of each defender. A piece that guards two things can be overloaded by a capture on one of them.
  • Material only matters if the opponent survives: Rubinstein was a queen and a rook down when he mated.
  • The decisive error often comes before the combination; here it was 19.e5, three moves earlier.
  • When your queen is attacked, look for a stronger threat before moving it: 22...Rxc3 ignored the attack on h4.

Want to turn one of your own games into a video? Try the ChessMotion Chess Video Maker.

Sources