Carlsen–Karjakin: the 2016 title-winning queen sacrifice

Magnus Carlsen retained the world title in the fourth rapid tiebreak against Sergey Karjakin with 50.Qh6+!, a queen sacrifice that forces mate. The final move is spectacular because the whole preceding attack makes both captures fail.

Complete game score

50 moves. Result: 1-0.

  1. 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 d6 3.d4 cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6 5.f3 e5 6.Nb3 Be7.
  2. 7.c4 a5 8.Be3 a4 9.Nc1 O-O 10.Nc3 Qa5 11.Qd2 Na6 12.Be2 Nc5.
  3. 13.O-O Bd7 14.Rb1 Rfc8 15.b4 axb3 16.axb3 Qd8 17.Nd3 Ne6 18.Nb4 Bc6.
  4. 19.Rfd1 h5 20.Bf1 h4 21.Qf2 Nd7 22.g3 Ra3 23.Bh3 Rca8 24.Nc2 R3a6.
  5. 25.Nb4 Ra5 26.Nc2 b6 27.Rd2 Qc7 28.Rbd1 Bf8 29.gxh4 Nf4 30.Bxf4 exf4.
  6. 31.Bxd7 Qxd7 32.Nb4 Ra3 33.Nxc6 Qxc6 34.Nb5 Rxb3 35.Nd4 Qxc4 36.Nxb3 Qxb3.
  7. 37.Qe2 Be7 38.Kg2 Qe6 39.h5 Ra3 40.Rd3 Ra2 41.R3d2 Ra3 42.Rd3 Ra7.
  8. 43.Rd5 Rc7 44.Qd2 Qf6 45.Rf5 Qh4 46.Rc1 Ra7 47.Qxf4 Ra2+ 48.Kh1 Qf2.
  9. 49.Rc8+ Kh7 50.Qh6+

What happened in this game?

The game grows from a restrained Sicilian into a long maneuvering struggle. Carlsen increases pressure with rooks on the d-file and wins queenside material, but Karjakin continues to create defensive resources.

Carlsen’s queen and rooks shift toward the king after 44.Qd2. The sequence 45.Rf5, 46.Rc1 and 47.Qxf4 brings every piece into the attack while Black’s rook is diverted to a2.

After 49.Rc8+ Kh7, 50.Qh6+! ends the match. If the king takes, 51.Rh8 is mate; if the pawn takes, 51.Rxf7 is mate. The finish is a textbook deflection pattern backed by exact control of the h-file and escape squares.

Twelve games, then the rapids

The 2016 World Championship was played in New York from 10 to 30 November. The first seven games were drawn, Karjakin won game 8, Carlsen won game 10, and the remaining games were drawn too, so the match ended 6–6 and went to rapid tiebreaks.

The first two rapid games were drawn and Carlsen won the third. Karjakin had to win the fourth with Black to stay in the match. The tiebreak fell on 30 November, the last day of the match and Carlsen’s 26th birthday.

Karjakin’s defence had been the story of the classical games. In game 3 he held a difficult ending for almost seven hours, a draw hailed as a miracle escape, and Carlsen said afterwards that he had never seen a clear win.

Carlsen had been champion since 2013, and Karjakin had earned the match by winning the 2016 Candidates Tournament. It was a best-of-twelve match, organised by FIDE with its commercial partner World Chess, formerly known as Agon.

Karjakin had to take risks

Karjakin chose the Sicilian Defence, the only time it appeared in the whole match. Carlsen played calmly, kept a position without weaknesses, and let Black’s need to win do the work. Karjakin might still have held a draw, but a draw was no use to him.

Stockfish 18 shows the edge growing slowly: about +1 for White around move 30 and nearly +3 by move 45, with Black’s rooks busy on the queenside, far from their own king.

Two captures, two mates

50.Qh6+ offers the queen with check, and both ways of taking it are mate. After 50...Kxh6, 51.Rh8# mates on the h-file; after 50...gxh6, 51.Rxf7# mates on the seventh rank. Stockfish confirms it as mate in two.

It is also the only move that wins. Several natural alternatives lose: 50.Rh8+ allows mate in four for Black, and 50.Qg3 mate in three, because Black’s own pieces were ready to strike. Lubomir Kavalek called it the most brilliant final move in the history of the World Championship.

After the match

Annotating for ChessBase, David Navara wrote that Carlsen deserved the title as the world’s best player for many years, and that Karjakin deserved credit for showing that Carlsen could be matched on even terms. Karjakin said he had played well below his capabilities in the tiebreaks.

What else was playable?

Checked with python-chess and Stockfish 18:

  • 50.Qh6+: Mate in two: 50...Kxh6 51.Rh8# or 50...gxh6 51.Rxf7#.
  • 50.Rh8+ (instead): Loses: Stockfish finds mate in four for Black.
  • 50.Qg3: Also loses, to mate in three.
  • 45...Qh6 (instead of 45...Qh4): About +2.3 against +2.8: Black was already worse either way.

What to take away

  • Check what every capture of a sacrificed piece allows. Here both captures were mate.
  • When the opponent must win, a calm, weakness-free position is often the strongest weapon.
  • In a position full of threats, the brilliant move may also be the only one that does not lose.
  • A sacrifice with check removes the opponent’s choices. Count the replies first, then calculate each one.

Want to turn one of your own games into a video? Try the ChessMotion Chess Video Maker.

Sources