Bishop and knight mate

The hardest of the basic mates, and the only one with a deadline. Mate exists, but only in a corner the bishop controls — and the fifty-move rule is close enough to matter.

The position

White to move.

  1. 1.Nf3+ Kd5 2.Bb3+ Ke4 3.Ke2 Kf5 4.Ke3 Kf6.

Why does this work?

A bishop only ever covers one colour, so mate can only be delivered in a corner of that colour. A defender who understands this runs for the wrong corner, and the whole technique is about not letting that happen.

The knight is the slow piece and it does the awkward work: it covers the squares the bishop cannot reach, which means it has to be repositioned constantly as the king is driven along the edge.

The tablebase says mate in 29 moves from this position, and no position of this kind needs more than 33. The fifty-move limit leaves room for that — but far less than in any other basic mate, which is why this one is worth drilling rather than reasoning out at the board.

The one basic mate with a deadline

Every other elementary mate is comfortable. This one has a deadline that matters in practice. The tablebase gives mate in 29 moves from the position shown, and from almost any starting position it can be forced within 33. The fifty-move rule allows for that, but the margin shrinks quickly once real inaccuracies are added, and a player who has not drilled it often does not finish in time.

That alone makes it worth learning properly rather than reasoning about at the board — it is the classic example of an ending where knowledge and strength come apart.

Why the corner matters

A bishop covers one colour, permanently. Mate can therefore only be delivered in a corner of that colour, and a defender who understands this heads straight for the wrong one.

So the technique has two phases that are usually taught as one: drive the king to the edge, then walk it along the edge to the correct corner. The second phase is the hard one, and it is where the knight does its awkward, repetitive repositioning.

The knight is the slow piece

A knight cannot lose a tempo and cannot cover a square adjacent to the one it stands on. Every time the barrier needs to move, the knight has to be brought round, and the king must hold everything together while it travels.

This is why the ending feels fiddly compared with two bishops. Nothing about it is deep; it is precise, which is a different kind of difficulty.

Grandmasters who ran out of moves

Even grandmasters have reached this ending and failed to win it. Vladimir Epishin had the bishop and knight against Robert Kempinski in the Bundesliga in 2001, tried for a while to mate in the wrong corner, and ended up stalemating the king after a fifty-move draw could already have been claimed.

Former Women’s World Champion Anna Ushenina missed two chances against Olga Girya in Geneva in the 2013–14 Women’s Grand Prix, and that game was drawn under the fifty-move rule. The ending can decide titles too: Tal Shaked knew the method, beat Alexander Morozevich with it in the penultimate round of the 1997 World Junior Championship, and won the title, which a draw would have cost him.

Two ways to learn it

There are two standard methods. Philidor described the knight’s route along the edge, now called the W manoeuvre, in the 1777 edition of his treatise. Daniel Delétang published a system of three shrinking triangles in 1923; it is not the fastest method, but it is simple, and it mates inside the fifty-move limit as long as the king is trapped in reasonable time.

Whether to learn it at all is a fair question, because the ending turns up in roughly one game in six thousand. Some authors leave it out of their endgame courses for that reason, while Andy Soltis argues that the techniques it teaches carry over to other endings.

What else was playable?

Verified against Syzygy tablebases from the position shown:

  • 1.Nf3+ (the line shown): One of five equally fast moves in the tablebase: mate in 29 with best play from both sides.
  • 1.Bf5: The only first move that does not win. It puts the bishop next to the black king, and king and knight cannot mate.
  • Aiming for the wrong corner: No mate exists there. The bishop cannot control the mating square, so the defender is safe.

What to take away

  • Mate is only possible in a corner the bishop’s colour controls — the defender will run for the other one.
  • Two phases: to the edge first, then along the edge to the right corner.
  • Count the moves. Up to 33 against a fifty-move limit means this must be known, not worked out.

Want a looping version of a position like this? Create an animated chess GIF with the Chess GIF Maker.

Sources