The Immortal Game queen sacrifice

Anderssen has already given up both rooks. His queen is the last major piece left—and offering it with check makes a mate by bishop and knight unavoidable.

The position

White to move.

  1. 22.Qf6+ Nxf6 23.Be7#

Why does this work?

22.Qf6+! leaves Black two legal replies: the knight on g8 captures, or it blocks on e7 and is mated at once. Black has no time to use the queen and rooks already collected on the other side of the board.

The capture clears e7 for 23.Be7#. The bishop checks on the diagonal while the knight on g7 and Black’s own pieces remove every flight square.

The sacrifice is sound because it is forcing from start to finish: check, a capture or a block, then checkmate. Material never gets another move.

What White has left

By move 22 Anderssen has given away both rooks and a bishop. Black’s queen stands on a1 and a black bishop on g1, deep in White’s camp, and on paper Black is winning comfortably. None of that matters if the king on d8 is mated first, and White’s remaining pieces are all aimed at it.

The knight on g7 covers e8. The knight on d5 covers c7 and e7. The bishop on d6 is ready to check from e7. The only black piece besides the king holding the position together is the knight on g8, which guards e7.

How Anderssen came to be two rooks down

The material went in a few moves. After 17.Nd5 Qxb2, Anderssen played 18.Bd6, offering both rooks at once. Black took one with 18...Bxg1, and White answered with the quiet 19.e5, which shuts the black queen out of the defence and threatens mate in two. 19...Qxa1+ 20.Ke2 Na6 21.Nxg7+ Kd8 brings the game to this position.

The annotations are frank about how sound that was. Robert Hübner found at least three better moves than 18.Bd6 that win without giving up so much, and Steinitz suggested in 1879 that Black should first have taken the other rook with check. The finish is forced; the road to it was not.

What the queen sacrifice removes

22.Qf6+ attacks the king and offers the queen to the g8-knight. Black has only two legal replies. 22...Nxf6 takes the queen, and in doing so the knight abandons e7. 22...Ne7 blocks instead, and is mated at once by either 23.Qxe7 or 23.Bxe7.

So the sacrifice is not a hope that Black will take. It leaves Black two moves, and both lose to mate on the next move. That is the cleanest kind of sacrifice to calculate, and it is why this one can be checked completely at the board.

Who covers what after 23.Be7#

The bishop checks from e7, and the knight on d5 protects it, so the king cannot capture. The same knight covers c7, and the knight on g7 covers e8. The last two squares, c8 and d7, are blocked by Black’s own bishop and pawn.

Notice what is missing from that list. White mates with three minor pieces against a queen, two rooks and a bishop, and not one of Black’s major pieces can reach the king in time. Material that is far from the action is simply not part of the fight.

Was the finish played at all?

The Immortal Game was a casual game, played in London in 1851 while the great tournament was under way but not as part of it. Kieseritzky published it soon afterwards, and by his own account he resigned at move 20, before this position arose.

A report published in 1893 suggested he played 20...Na6 and Anderssen then announced the mate rather than playing it out. Either way, the queen sacrifice is usually reproduced as if it happened on the board, and it may not have. The finish is still correct, and it is still how the game is remembered.

What else was playable?

White has thirty-nine legal moves and several of them win. Stockfish 18 rates two of them as forced mates.

  • 22.Qxf7: Also a forced mate, in four by Stockfish’s count. Black can throw in a couple of checks, but they run out and the queen finishes on f8.
  • 22.Qf4 or 22.Qf5: About +7. Winning comfortably, but Black gets ...Bc5 and ...Qxe5+ in and the game goes on.
  • 22...Ne7 (instead of 22...Nxf6): The only other legal reply. It blocks the check and is mated at once, by 23.Qxe7 or 23.Bxe7.

What to take away

  • List the defender’s replies before you judge a sacrifice. Two replies, both mated, is a calculation, not a risk.
  • Find the piece guarding the mating square, then look for a check that forces it to move.
  • Famous scores are not always what was played. Check how a game is recorded as having ended.

Want a looping version of a position like this? Create an animated chess GIF with the Chess GIF Maker.

Sources